The Evening Edition (10¢)
Although once one of the most revered sources of inspiration and design industry news, Stylegala has, suffice to say, gone to hell. Gallery updates have slowly come to a halt, news is littered with useless and tasteless links, and the forum has been overrun by spammers and old owners selling their new endeavors. It’s a freaking mess, and apparently the owner doesn’t know what to do now.
I loved Stylegala for what it once was, but so much has changed that I fear it may be lost to the idle hands of the current owner (no offense, but more steps could be taken in my opinion). So, because no one seems to be stepping up and putting themselves out there, and the people are ready to leave, here’s how we could save Stylegala:
Stylegala’s forum is overrun with spam.
I know that sounds like a bad omen from the start, but there’s only one way to stop the downward spiral: cut it off before it reaches the end. Take the step to put forth your best effort to fixing the site by enabling absolute power to do so. If you work hard enough, and have enough support from the community (I know enough people would step up, myself included), Stylegala won’t be lost to the abyss.
Close the site for 2 months and come back with a more secure and reliable system that people can gather around and lift up. If you do it right and come back with flying colors, you can get the ads back, start earning revenue, and maybe even pass profit sharing to those who regularly contribute to the site. Whatever the case, you’ll come back stronger.
And if possible, just start from scratch. Honestly, the best way to fix a struggling site is to rethink it’s entire purpose and architecture. If it were not for the news being regularly updated (even with the all the spam that it was once subject to), the site would be almost completely dead.
Let’s face it, you need to put time and effort into this to make it work. The design and UI suffer, the backend seems limp as bacon, and the site is abused (even by it’s old owner). Rework the backend to solve the problems that plague the current site. Make it better, faster, stronger.
You’ve got volunteers that want to help write for the site, so why not get them on board? They say they are intimidated by the history of Stylegala, but I think they haven’t been properly motivated to learn from that and move on. Stylegala is at the place that it is today because of it’s stagnant nature.
Am I saying we abandon our beliefs and expectations? Give up hope on the perfect website? No, not at all. On the contrary, I say we recognize sites that strive for the best, but come up short. How can we help them? Constructive criticism, commentary from a caring community, and effort by the admins and contributors.
So get those articles flowing in at a steady pace. While the site is down, stack them up so that you have an arsenal just ready to blast the Internet with when you come back.
What is Stylegala? Three things come to mind: community news, design showcase, and forum. For the time being, cut the fat that is hardly ever updated and come back to it when you have the time, energy, and stability across the site to properly do so. Don’t give something you care deeply about anything short of your best.
While the site is down for those two months, remove the Bookstore, the Software Store, the Resources, the Features, and whatever else can stand to go to bring back the news, gallery, and forum. Focused bursts will be your key to success.
Let’s face it, we all love Stylegala’s, well, style, but the site’s visual design has passed it’s prime and needs to be refreshed. The code, the visuals, and the interactions are haphazardly pieced together, and leave little for those featured in the gallery to really look up to.
The site needs to be redesigned (I’m not saying I have the perfect design in mind, but I have one in the works) to promote those three sellable and most important features mentioned above (news, forum, and gallery). From the Google Ads that look like the navigation to form interaction to semantics, Stylegala could use some of that pizzazz that Stylegala’s own readers know and love.
And there you have it: five steps that would get Stylegala back on it’s feet and ready to kick some ass. It seems like a lot of work—that’s because it is. Did you expect anything else?
Copyright © 2008 Mark Otto.
R.Bhavesh
Agree with you mark. I remember your redesign of SG. The owners of that site seems to be gone behind the doors since they bought it from Monc.
Anyways, I admire your work since 2005. Would love if you post more of your work on your blog.
Thanks
Mark
R. Bhavesh:
Thanks, for both the compliments and your comment in general. Thanks for the dedication!
It seems that whoever did buy the domain, even though they gave it a rough go around the past few months, have given up altogether.
We’ll see where this takes us.
David
I popped in here from a link on a comment you made and saw the title and was ready to lay it into you about how stylegala needs more supporters and less critics, but after reading the article, I 100% with everything you have stated here save shutting the site down, I think everything you are talking about can be done live would also help to assure people that the site was not finally dead for real with a forever ‘down’ sign that never goes away. or a date for relaunch that starts to creep.
I myself have made sever unanswered request to Simon about selling the site or doing a partnership where he is silent part and gains a percent of revenue while I take over the day to day of it all, but to no avail, I mean i understand 30k is a lot of money to have plunked down, but having your investment go to $0 just doesn’t seem to make sense. I’ll keep privately trying to see whats up with Simon and he site, please email me when you have a mock for the site i remember long time ago you did a redesign of stylegala, was that you? Anyway shoot me an email someone like you would be high on my list as a person to help out have a revenue share if anything develops.